Overthink to Overdrive (free yourself of analysis paralysis)

When speaking with auto shop owner clients or even local business owners, they tell me stories of how challenging it is to make business decisions at times. In many cases they say they aren’t as confident in their decisions as they want to be. They feel that there is so much to know about business and so much to keep up with. They’re correct!

Every owner is good or even great at some areas of business but not all. List which of the 5 areas of business you’re good or even great at. Then list the ones that need improvement.

  • Marketing
  • Sales
  • Operations
  • People
  • Financials

All areas are equally important to succeed. The key is to get comfortable in each area. Comfortable not complacent. Most owners don’t feel comfortable and can lead to putting off activities they believe will take a lot of time. In many cases they’re not sure where to start.

Overthinking – Let’s Get Clear

Owners are faced with so many decisions and with many so caught up in the day to day, no wonder they feel a sense of overload.

Maryann Photo For Feb ArticleToo Much Information: Makes it hard to know what is best for your stage of business and life.

Fear of Making Mistakes: Mistakes that can affect short- and long-term business success.

Lack of Clarity: Having to put out fires daily can hold owners back from planning.

Inadequate Information: Questioning the source of information is common.

Perceived Consequences: What owners think may happen may not be realistic.

Decision-Making Framework

When owners delay important decisions, they miss opportunities or become stuck in a cycle of overthinking. To overcome analysis paralysis, it’s important to streamline the decision-making process. This allows business owners to make more informed and timely choices to grow their business.

  1. Define Goals and Identify Challenges: What do you want to achieve and pinpoint the main challenges.
  2. Get Information and Ideas: Collect information and brainstorm solutions.
  3. Evaluate Options and Seek Input: Weigh the pros and cons of each solution and get feedback from others if possible.
  4. Make an Informed Decision: Choose the best solution based on information and feedback.
  5. Create an Action Plan and Monitor Progress: Develop a plan, act, and monitor progress adjusting as needed.

Shift to Overdrive

Minimizing assumptions is the foundation of effective decision-making and problem-solving. Relying on assumptions can introduce unnecessary risks and errors into the decision-making process. Here’s why reducing assumptions is important to making confident and quicker decisions:

  • Accuracy: With concrete data and facts, there is no guessing. Assumptions can lead to inaccurate conclusions.
  • Mitigating Risks: Make decisions with a solid foundation to reduce challenges or failures. Assumptions can be risky.
  • Building Confidence: When decisions are grounded in facts, owners/leaders have greater confidence in their choices.
  • Better Planning: Accurate information allows for better planning and resource allocation, reducing costly mistakes.
  • Effective Communication: Everyone is on the same page with clear information. Minimizing assumptions improves communication.

The path of least assumptions is best. Don’t stay stuck in overthinking and allow analysis paralysis to get the best of you. Seek guidance to hone your leadership skills. A business will grow only to the level of the owner’s leadership. Reach out to a coach, mentor or another business owner who understands and has experience.

  • Structured Decision-Making: Decision making framework.
  • Goal Setting: Goals that work for your stage of business and life.
  • Accountability: Celebrate wins big and small. Focus on acting, instead of excessive analysis.

Don’t be hard on yourself. Getting comfortable with all the areas of your business is a journey. Once you have a framework or process, your confidence will increase and you’ll make better decisions based on your stage of business and stage of life, not someone else’s.


Maryann CroceMaryann Croce, a certified partner of Todd Herman’s 90 Day Year™, is a coach/speaker and creator of ‘3-Day Weekends’ System. Her company Small Biz Vantage specialized in performance and leadership for automotive and skilled trade business owners. She has been an auto shop owner since 1999. 

You can reach Maryann at (203) 913-7741 or maryann@SmallBizVantage.com Maryann speaks on strategies to achieve work-life fulfillment SmallBizVantage.com